Brandon Marcus
@brandonjmarc
Brandon Marcus
@brandonjmarc
... See moreCreedal nationalism was an attempt to explain the continuity of American institutions despite the transformation of its population. The nation could absorb so much immigration, liberal theorists reasoned, because its essence lay in ideas rather than in blood, soil, or religious confession. Unlike European nations, argued philosopher John Dewey,
... See more…the fifty years that followed the First World War were characterized by the most intense assimilative pressure of any in American history. Yet the theoretical and practical limitations of the melting pot could not be ignored by a country increasingly defined by ideological conflict rather than by national expansion. In its confrontation with
... See moreRather than trying to restore an elusive consensus, I propose that we strengthen institutions of contestation. Our problem, in other words, is not that we have forgotten how much Americans have in common, but that we have undermined or abandoned structures and organizations that express and embody disagreement. Political parties, labor unions, and