Margaret Heffernan: Embracing Uncertainty and Creativity

Creativity and the Writing Process

Heffernan emphasizes collaboration and critique: “That dissent is absolutely fundamental to the creative process,” she notes, explaining how colleagues’ pushback can turn a raw idea into something “marvelous” .
She argues that supportive environments spark creativity: “To foster creativity, organisations must create environments where all voices are valued, curiosity is encouraged, and psychological safety is prioritised,” promoting inclusive, curious work cultures .
Highlighting the importance of observation, Heffernan adds: “It’s impossible to be creative without being a noticer… being observant and thinking about what you see… keeps you much more in touch with what’s going on in the world.”

The Role of Uncertainty in Artistic Work

Heffernan observes that rigid certainty stifles creativity: “Absolute certainty removes freedom… Innovation thrives in uncertainty,” illustrating that open-ended, unpredictable conditions fuel imaginative breakthroughs .
She calls uncertainty “life’s richness,” explaining: “If everything were certain, there would be no innovation, no imagination, no possibility.” In other words, the unknown is “the space where we explore and create” .
Noting artists’ attitude toward risk, Heffernan writes: “Artists aren’t afraid of uncertainty; they move towards it… because that’s where breakthroughs happen.” She underscores that creators (like scientists) welcome complexity and ambiguity as the source of innovation .
In conversation she adds that dealing with uncertainty requires flexibility: “Uncertainty requires that we loosen up in order to be able to respond more flexibly,” suggesting that being adaptable is key to creative survival .

Impact of AI on Artists and Writers

Heffernan warns that AI’s strength comes from artists’ work: “Ever since ChatGPT bounced onto the scene, writers, musicians and visual artists have had to come face to face with the reality that this new technology acquires its ‘intelligence’ by scraping their work.” This highlights how AI training relies on existing creative output .
Pointing to legal issues, she writes: “AI flouts [copyright law] each time it scrapes an artist’s work; it’s like automating shoplifting.” AI’s unlicensed copying undermines artists’ rights and earnings .
Heffernan notes a threat to livelihoods: “Artists’ ability to earn income from their work is threatened by AI’s capacity to generate a limitless number of derivative works.” In short, AI could flood the market and devalue original creative labor .
She also critiques the polarized debate around AI: “The battle for and against AI is starting to feel like a war… the reality is that its outcome will change our lives. Just not in the way you might think,” suggesting that the real cultural impact of AI is complex and unexpected .

Navigating Turbulent Social and Technological Change

Reflecting on institutional resilience, Heffernan observes that “their ability to [adapt and change] is really what keeps them relevant. We have to think about healthy institutions being those that change as we do and as society does.” In other words, organizations (and creators) survive by evolving with changing times .
She cautions against haste in decision-making during change: “There is a misconception that faster decisions are better… Companies that endure… invest in thought, learning, and measured decision-making rather than impulsive action.” Thoughtful, deliberate choices help navigate complexity more successfully than brute speed .

Sources: Quotes and insights are drawn from Margaret Heffernan’s recent interviews and writings, as cited above . These reflect her views on creativity, uncertainty, AI, and change.

The passion of the posts

Most Human Wins