Saved by Sam Liebeskind
What We Lose When Optimizing Community
These are the run clubs and swim clubs with very robustly branded websites for some reason, websites that greet you with full-width videos of delighted people being very sweaty together. New ventures for “group conversation” or exclusive social spaces or curated clubs with sign-up flows and membership levels that evoke the rigor of a bank account... See more
Elise Granata • What We Lose When Optimizing Community
a great website and active social media presence does not mean community is being “done wrong” and we aren’t failing by wanting to know as much as we can to be comfortable. And I don’t want to pedestalize every experience with no upfront information. It is crucial to know if you can physically access a space, for example, or will be able to... See more
Elise Granata • What We Lose When Optimizing Community
A caveat worth mentioning when trying to place communities in the “bad community” basket, if ever that’s a worthwhile exercise
Good branding signals other things related to class and positionality – if an experience looks good, it’s because it was crafted at some point by a designer and a creative director who had the time, skills, and zeitgeist awareness to know what looks good (one of the founders of the swim club mentioned above is a graphic designer by trade, as an... See more
Elise Granata • What We Lose When Optimizing Community
In CAPS LOCK , Ruben Pater traces the evolution of branding from livestock to slavery to mass-produced goods. Today it has obviously gone lightyears further, grooming every part of an experience that may not even be associated with a product you can hold in your hands. He writes: “Even a well-designed brand for a museum still uses the same logic of... See more
Elise Granata • What We Lose When Optimizing Community
It may be more likely to be pay-to-play. Design takes time and effort. Content creation takes time and effort. Everything that goes into a shiny digital footprint – website design, hosting, platform service subscriptions – costs money. Compare this to a random book club meet-up advertised through a single flyer made by hand and stapled to a few... See more
Elise Granata • What We Lose When Optimizing Community
an argument against “pay to play”
More grassroots – and possibly more impactful – efforts feel less trustworthy. There is a community fridge in my city that has existed since 2021 and has a basic social media presence. But it isn’t updated often, and I find myself having a “huh maybe they’re not active anymore” assumption even though a) they posted 2 months ago and b) I could... See more
Elise Granata • What We Lose When Optimizing Community
Design takes time and effort. Content creation takes time and effort. Everything that goes into a shiny digital footprint – website design, hosting, platform service subscriptions – costs money. Compare this to a random book club meet-up advertised through a single flyer made by hand and stapled to a few telephone poles. On the other side of all... See more
Elise Granata • What We Lose When Optimizing Community
On how to spot pay-to-play communities
We lose the feeling that comes with a little mystery and a healthy amount of risk. When we don’t know exactly what’s going to happen, you know what happens? We get to be surprised. Our anticipation builds in the not knowing – better get there early to figure out getting in, ask others if it’s their first time, scan a pamphlet for clues or read... See more
Elise Granata • What We Lose When Optimizing Community
you don’t always have to know