
Manna: Two Visions of Humanity's Future

The government had finally figured out that giving choices to people on welfare was not such a great idea, and it was also expensive. Instead of giving people a welfare check, they started putting welfare recipients directly into government housing and serving them meals in a cafeteria. If the government could drive the cost of that housing and foo
... See moreMarshall Brain • Manna: Two Visions of Humanity's Future
We're on a roller coaster to the lowest common denominator.
There are immensely rich people in the U.S., but they all seem to have large egos. They would rather compete and bash each other than cooperate. They are constantly suing one another. And none of them wants to have anything to do with taxes. With all that happening, it is very hard to get people together to work on big projects. It makes it much ha
... See moreMarshall Brain • Manna: Two Visions of Humanity's Future
How would the US respond to what is happening at this moment in the story within Australia? It seems unlikely that the elites of America would just sit idly by while the world continues to lap what is available to its wealthiest.
"The robots won't let you walk away because, if they did, you would end up as a homeless person on some city street. Without a job, you are by default homeless in the American economy. None of the wealthy people want to look at homeless people, so you are warehoused here and forced to stay here."
Marshall Brain • Manna: Two Visions of Humanity's Future
"Will we ever make love together?" I asked. "I cannot predict the future." She said. "But I would say that the probability of that event is high." I looked at her and she looked at me for a moment.
Marshall Brain • Manna: Two Visions of Humanity's Future
That just took a turn for the worse. Probably the most tacked-on romantic angle I have ever seen.
it's all free. By being a shareholder, you already own your share of the resources. The robots make products from the free resources you and everyone else already owns. There is no forced labor like there is in America. You do what you want, and you get 1,000 credits per week. We are all on an endless vacation."
Marshall Brain • Manna: Two Visions of Humanity's Future
Then why the hell didn't you find the guy before he had to spend a year in this shit-hole housing project?
In the U.S., everyone had to work, and in most cases "work" meant doing something that a rich person wanted so that the rich person could get richer.
Marshall Brain • Manna: Two Visions of Humanity's Future
Capitalism is turning into more and more of a multi-level marketing machine.
In Australia, these people could completely fulfill themselves, and humanity would be much better off because of their contributions. Creative people want to -- need to -- create. That is their passion. Instead of millions of talented people working in jobs that had nothing to do with their dreams, simply to make ends meet, in Australia they could
... See moreMarshall Brain • Manna: Two Visions of Humanity's Future
Is it really true that, if people had full autonomy, that they would self-select into roles requiring tons of rigorous specialization and oversight by more experienced mentors? A society organized like this may lack structural engineers, specialized medicine, etc.
The switchover to robots was proceeding with remarkable speed, and for some reason it seemed like no one had really thought about the effects of the transition. All of these people being replaced by the robots needed some form of income to survive, but the job pool was shrinking. The American "service economy" was what replaced the "
... See moreMarshall Brain • Manna: Two Visions of Humanity's Future
An important note if you are in one of the jobs made up of monotonous tasks strung together - your runway is not long. Best to seek non-automatable work ASAP (and yes, I realize that any person I am describing here, is unlikely to see this note).
How would you create a different society, rather than living like this?" "I have no idea. And even if I did, it wouldn't change anything."
Marshall Brain • Manna: Two Visions of Humanity's Future
Hopeless people are depressing.